Interior Defensive Line Free Agents



With the NFL owners’ lockout coming to an end, one of the first things that will get done on the agenda for the 2011 season is the free agent signing period.
Compressed into a week to 10 days rather than several months, the run to free agency will be fast and frantic. It will come after a two or three-day window where teams will have an exclusive shot at re-signing their own free agents.
As one of the NFL teams that must spend a lot of money in the 2011 season to reach the minimum level of spending under the salary cap, the Chiefs figure to be a buyer in this postponed free agency period. Knowing how the front office under GM Scott Pioli works, they will approach the free-agent market with very specific plans; the chance the Chiefs spend willy-nilly on free agents is very low.
Due to the lack of off-season preparation time, teams figure to be more likely to spend the money necessary to keep their own free agents. That’s especially true for the Chiefs as they speak often of the culture they are trying to create and the type of personalities that fit into that team picture.
One spot that will require their attention will be the defensive line, specifically interior players for the nose tackle and defensive tackle positions.
The primary players at that spot in the 2010 Chiefs are free agents – Ron Edwards and Shaun Smith. Both players are not considered upper echelon talents; Edwards is average, while Smith is coming off the best season of his career, with contributions not only on the nose, but at defensive end.
At the start of free agency way back in late February-early March, there were two prime-time nose tackles that were scheduled to be unrestricted free agents – the Baltimore Ravens Haloti Ngata and Paul Soliai of the Miami Dolphins. Ngata is 6-4, 350 pounds and just 27 years old. Soliai is 6-4, 355 pounds and also 27 years old.
But alas, both Ngata and Soliai were slapped with the franchise player tag. Both players signed their $12.5 million tender offers for the 2011 season. That’s the storyline of free agency in the NFL – teams have learned to keep their own players, rather than spending large sums of money on players they don’t know.
The decision Pioli and folks must make is how much they can expect out of Edwards and Smith and how far they are going to dive into what is a shallow pool of free agents. A true nose tackle is one of the hardest positions to find in the NFL. While teams using the 3-4 defense have grown in number, they are all searching for that big man in the middle. They want someone between 6-2 and 6-5, anywhere from 325-360 pounds, with foot quickness and great strength. Those types of guys don’t just fall out of the football personnel trees, and thank goodness for that because they could hurt somebody.
Here’s the unofficial list of unrestricted free agents at DT/NT, plus a few guys who have played DE, but can move inside. We are working under the proviso that free agency will come to players who have played four years or more. Some players may be added to the list once teams can move players on and off their rosters.
The list has been broken down, creating categories based on talent, age and production. Included on the list are last year’s stats plus the ranking of the player’s defense in yards allowed against the run and pass during the ’10 season. Players marked with an * spent most of last season on the injured list.
And it all starts with Edwards and Smith.
|  Player |
 Old Team |
 Ht |
 Wt |
 Exp |
 Age |
 ’10 Tkl |
 ’10 Sks |
 FF |
 Rank  Run |
Rank  Pass |
| Ron Edwards |
KCÂ |
 6-3 |
 315 |
 10 |
 32 |
 26 |
 2 |
 0 |
 14 |
 17 |
| Shaun Smith |
 KC |
 6-2 |
 325 |
 6 |
 29 |
 56 |
 1 |
 0 |
 14 |
 17 |
Group A – The Best Available
|  Player |
 Old Team |
 Ht |
 Wt |
 Exp |
 Age |
 ’10 Tkl |
 ’10 Sks |
 FF |
 Rank Run |
 Rank  Pass |
| Anthony Adams |
 CHI |
 6-0 |
 310 |
 8 |
 31 |
 37 |
 2 |
 2 |
 2 |
 20 |
| Remi Ayodele |
 NO |
 6-2 |
 318 |
 4 |
 28 |
 68 |
 1 |
 1 |
 16 |
 4 |
| Aubrayo Franklin |
 SF |
 6-1 |
 317 |
 8 |
 30 |
 39 |
 0 |
 0 |
 6 |
 24 |
| Anthony Hargrove |
 NO |
 6-3 |
 272 |
 6 |
 27 |
 29 |
 1 |
 2 |
 16 |
 4 |
| Tommie Harris |
 CHI |
 6-3 |
 295 |
 7 |
 28 |
 13 |
 1.5 |
 0 |
 2 |
 20 |
| Tony (E) McDaniel |
 MIA |
 6-7 |
 305 |
 5 |
 26 |
 36 |
2.5 |
 0 |
 7 |
 8 |
| Daniel Muir |
 IND |
 6-2 |
 312 |
 4 |
 27 |
 38 |
 0 |
 0 |
 25 |
 13 |
Franklin is the guy who has drawn all the attention. He was the Niners franchise player last season and they were able to keep him for another year. When San Francisco played the Chiefs at Arrowhead Stadium in late September 2010, Franklin was very unimpressive; he had 4 tackles in a defense that allowed 457 yards in offense, including 207 rushing yards, at 5.3 yards per carry. Plus, Chiefs QB Matt Cassel was not sacked in the game on 27 passing plays.
The other players in this Class A category play either DT or DE – they are not first-down nose tackles. Adams and Ayodele are intriguing options, especially the second guy who is just 28 years old.
| Player |
 Old Team |
Ht |
 Wt |
 Exp |
 Age |
 ’10 Tkl |
 ’10 Sks |
 FF |
Rank Run
|
 Rank Pass |
| Pat Williams |
 MIN |
 6-3 |
 317 |
 14 |
 38 |
 30 |
 0 |
 1 |
 9 |
 10 |
| a |
 NYJ |
 6-4 |
 360 |
 10 |
 31 |
 1 |
 0 |
 0 |
 – |
|
| *Chris Hovan |
 STL |
 6-2 |
 300 |
 11 |
 33 |
 0 |
 0 |
 0 |
 – |
 – |
| *Robaire Smith (E) |
 CLV |
 6-5 |
 310 |
 11 |
 33 |
 25 |
 0 |
 0 |
 – |
 – |
| Bryan Robinson |
 ARZ |
 6-4 |
 305 |
 14 |
 37 |
 19 |
 0 |
 0 |
 30 |
 23 |
| Marques Douglas |
 TEN |
 6-2 |
 292 |
 10 |
 34 |
 21 |
 0 |
 0 |
 20 |
 29 |
| Chris Hoke |
 PIT |
 6-2 |
 305 |
 9 |
 35 |
 12 |
 0 |
 0 |
 1 |
 12 |
| Damione Lewis |
 HOU |
 6-2 |
 301 |
 10 |
 33 |
 17 |
 1 |
 0 |
 13 |
 32 |
| Jamal Williams |
 DEN |
 6-3 |
 348 |
 13 |
 35 |
 47 |
 0 |
 0 |
 31 |
 25 |
a – Jenkins announced his retirement on Wednesday.
There are familiar names in this group, including guys that in the past have played at a Pro Bowl level in the middle. That would guys like Pat and Jamal Williams, Kris Jenkins and Robaire Smith. Those first three are true nose tackles, while Smith is probably better suited to play DT or DE in the 3-4. But all three of those nose tackles are long in the tooth and Jenkins is coming off a pair of torn ACLs that came in 11 months, forcing him to miss all but the 2010 season opener.
Somebody from this group would be a stop-gap, a one-year band-aid at the position.
|  Player | Old Team |
 Ht |
 Wt |
 Exp |
 Age |
 ’10 Tkl |
 ’10 Sks |
FF |
 Rank Run |
 Rank Pass |
|||||||||||
| Justin Bannan |
 DEN |
 6-3 |
 310 |
 9 |
 32 |
 35 |
 1 |
 1 |
 31 |
 25 |
|||||||||||
| Ronald Fields |
 DEN |
 6-2 |
 314 |
 6 |
 29 |
 22 |
 0 |
 0 |
 31 |
 25 |
|||||||||||
| Brandon Mebane |
 SEA |
 6-1 |
 311 |
 4 |
 26 |
 31 |
 1 |
 0 |
 21 |
 27 |
|||||||||||
| Gerard Warren |
 NE |
 6-4 |
 330 |
 10 |
 32 |
 28 |
 3.5 |
 0 |
 11 |
 30 |
|||||||||||
| Craig Terrill |
 SEA |
 6-2 |
 296 |
 7 |
 31 |
 10 |
 0 |
 0 |
 21 |
 27 |
|||||||||||
| Gary Gibson |
 STL |
 6-3 |
 300 |
 5 |
 29 |
 18 |
 0 |
 0 |
 17 |
 19 |
|||||||||||
| Gabe Watson |
 ARZ |
 6-4 |
 338 |
 5 |
 27 |
 8 |
 0 |
 0 |
 30 |
 23 |
|||||||||||
| Antonio Johnson |
 IND |
 6-3 |
 310 |
 4 |
 26 |
 26 |
 ½ |
 0 |
 25 |
 13 |
|||||||||||
| *Junior Siavii |
 SEA |
 6-5 |
 315 |
 4 |
 32 |
 30 |
 0 |
 0 |
 21 |
 27 |
|||||||||||
| Alan Branch |
 ARZ |
 6-6 |
 338 |
 4 |
 26 |
 36 |
 2 |
 2 |
 30 |
 23 |
|||||||||||
| Barry Cofield |
 NYG |
 6-4 |
 306 |
 5 |
 27 |
 60 |
 4 |
 2 |
 8 |
 9 |
|||||||||||
| Derek Landri |  CAR |
 6-2 |
290 |
 4 |
 27 |
 43 |
 3 |
 0 |
 23 |
 11 |
|||||||||||
| Marcus Thomas |
 DEN |
 6-3 |
 316 |
 4 |
 25 |
 35 |
 1 |
 0 |
 31 |
 25 |
|||||||||||
There are some familiar names in this group for head coach Todd Haley, with a pair of Arizona Cardinals in Gabe Watson and Alan Branch. There’s also a familiar name for Chiefs fans in Junior Siavii, who after failing so poorly while wearing red and gold, has stitched together a career playing for Dallas and Seattle.
 The cream of the crop in this category is Barry Cofield from the Giants; last year he had 60 tackles and four sacks for one of the best defenses in the NFL in 2010.
| Â Player |
 Old Team |
 Ht |
 Wt |
 Exp |
 Age |
 ’10 tkls |
 ’10 sks |
 FF |
Rank Run |
|
| *John McCargo |
 BUF |
 6-2 |
 307 |
 5 |
 27 |
 1 |
 0 |
 0 |
 – |
 – |
| Amon Gordon |
 SEA |
 6-2 |
 305 |
 6 |
 29 |
 2 |
 0 |
 0 |
 21 |
 27 |
| *Justin Harrell |
 GB |
 6-4 |
 315 |
 4 |
 27 |
 0 |
 0 |
 0 |
 18 |
 5 |
| Clifton Ryan |
 STL |
 6-3 |
 324 |
 4 |
 27 |
 0 |
 0 |
 0 |
 17 |
 19 |
| Fred Evans |
 MIN |
 6-4 |
 305 |
 5 |
 27 |
 4 |
 0 |
 0 |
 9 |
 10 |
Several draft disappointments in this group for Buffalo in John McCargo and Green Bay with Justin Harrell. Injuries and lack of production have held each of these guys back and they are not likely tos be considered by the Chiefs.


Bob if you had to make a guess, which NT would you expect KC to sign? Do you think KC would give a large contract to Franklin, who some say will only play good during a contract year? If you had to name a sleeper who would it be?
the nfl needs to get a CBA in so that all of this can happen