Pre-Season Rankings – Week #3
We promised you weekly rankings during the pre-season on the Chiefs unwieldy roster of nearly 90 players. After the game in Baltimore, we got sidetracked by several important items.
But before they hit the field for pre-season game No. 3, it was time to break the club down position-by-position. With the cut next week moving the roster to 85 players, and then a few days later falling all the way to 53, there are a lot of decisions that must be made in a very short time.
Here’s this man’s opinions on where these 89 players rank at their spot and who has reasons to be looking over their shoulder for the fabled “Turk” the mythical figure who brings news of football unemployment. Every player is ranked either going up, down or hanging steady.
Also those shaded in gray are very much on the roster bubble or their chances are someplace worse.
Feel free to agree, disagree or argue. But there’s no doubt the clock is ticking down on the 2011 NFL pre-season.
Quarterbacks
| Rank | Player |
 |
Comment | ||
|
1. |
Matt Cassel |
 |
Offense has struggled, so has #7 | ||
|
2. |
Tyler Palko |
 |
Quirky style, but gutty passer | ||
|
3. |
Ricky Stanzi |
 |
Hard to improve w/no protection | ||
Comments: Still expecting the Chiefs to add a veteran QB of some kind, although Palko’s performance vs. Ravens certainly solidified his spot.
Running backs
| Rank | Player |  | Comment |
|
1. |
Jamaal Charles |
|
Leg tweak a concern right now |
|
2. |
Le’Ron McClain |
|
Getting into shape; hard runner |
|
3. |
Thomas Jones |
|
Lost pounds and seems quicker |
|
4. |
Dexter McCluster |
|
Better suited coming out as RB |
|
5. |
Jackie Battle |
|
He is what he is: tough, reliable |
|
6. |
Mike Cox |
|
He is what he is: tough, reliable |
|
7. |
Shane Bannon |
|
Not flashed at any point |
|
8. |
Tervaris Johnson |
|
Missed time to injury hurts him |
Comments: The question is whether they carry two fullbacks or not. They have in the past, but that was due to special teams play. Cox, Bannon and Johnson don’t show up much in the kicking game.
Wide receivers
| Rank | Player | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Comment |
|
1. |
Dwayne Bowe |
|
Has had very good camp |
|
2. |
Steve Breaston |
|
Starting to show himself |
|
3. |
Jerheme Urban |
|
Played well at times |
|
4. |
Keary Colbert |
|
Surprise of pre-season; |
|
5. |
Jonathan Baldwin |
|
Disappointment before injury |
|
6. |
Terrance Copper |
|
Special teams will be his card |
|
7. |
Verran Tucker |
|
Will battle Copper for last spot |
|
8. |
Zeke Markshausen |
|
Too much ground to cover |
|
9. |
Jeremy Horne |
|
He’s taken step back from ’10 |
|
10. |
Chandler Williams |
|
Can’t gain any traction |
|
11. |
Josue Paul |
|
Not much to see so far |
|
12. |
Chris Manno |
|
Not much to see so far |
Comments: Will it be five or six receivers? If it’s six, there’s competition for that last spot. Otherwise the position appears to be closed.
Tight ends
| Rank | Player | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Comment |
|
1. |
Tony Moeaki |
|
Made up for missed time quickly |
|
2. |
Leonard Pope |
|
Hasn’t shown much this camp |
|
3. |
Jake O’Connell |
|
Ankle injury comes at bad times |
|
4. |
Cody Slate |
|
Has some receiving skills |
|
5. |
Charlie Gantt |
|
Struggled to handle position |
|
6. |
Anthony Becht |
? |
His talents give him a chance |
Comments: After Moeaki it appears to be a position where anything could happen. Pope and O’Connell could come back as a pair, or two new faces could move into the jobs. Stay tuned.
Offensive line
| Rank | Player | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Comment |
|
1. |
Branden Albert |
|
Still an ascending player at LT |
|
2. |
Jon Asamoah |
|
No problem stepping in at RG |
|
3. |
Ryan Lilja |
|
Veteran back at familiar LG |
|
4. |
Rodney Hudson |
|
Rookie has worked both C/G |
|
5. |
Casey Wiegmann |
|
Veteran keeps getting it done |
|
6. |
Barry Richardson |
|
Has looked good at times |
|
7. |
Butch Lewis |
|
Rookie free agent can play G/T |
|
8. |
Ryan O’Callaghan |
|
Injury doesn’t help his chances |
|
9. |
Darryl Harris |
|
Injury doesn’t help his chances |
|
10. |
Bobby Greenwood |
|
Now working at both C/G |
|
11. |
Jared Gaither |
|
Can’t stay on the practice field |
|
12. |
Mike Ingersoll |
|
Can play all five spots |
|
13. |
David Mims |
|
Nice tools; green as grass |
|
14. |
Chris Harr |
|
Struggled but he works hard |
|
15. |
Lucas Patterson  |
|
Struggled but he works hard |
Comments: Figure 9 or 10 blockers on the final roster, so there should be a real battle for the last two spots. Versatility will be the key.
Defensive linemen
| Rank | Player | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Comment |
|
1. |
Glenn Dorsey |
|
Making continued improvement |
|
2. |
Wallace Gilberry |
|
Trying to match run vs. pass skills |
|
3. |
Allen Bailey |
|
Rookie has chance to contribute |
|
4. |
Kelly Gregg |
|
Question: how long can he play? |
|
5. |
Tyson Jackson |
|
Improved; needs consistency |
|
6. |
Dion Gales |
|
Really stepped up his game |
|
7. |
Brandon Bair |
|
Rookie has skills to rush passer |
|
8. |
Jerrell Powe |
|
Big guy has been inconsistent |
|
9. |
Amon Gordon |
|
Journeyman has roster chance |
|
10. |
Harold Ayodele |
|
Late arrival shows a spark |
|
11. |
Anthony Toribio |
|
Knee injury killing his chances |
Comments: They’ll carry six, possibly seven, so there are not of spots open here after Jackson.
Linebackers
| Rank | Player | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Comment |
|
1. |
Tamba Hali |
|
Working hard with new $$ |
|
2. |
Derrick Johnson |
|
Working hard with new $$ |
|
3. |
Justin Houston |
|
Making up for lost time |
|
4. |
Andy Studebaker |
|
Solid summer without fanfare |
|
5. |
Cameron Sheffield |
|
He’s back strong from injury |
|
6. |
Jovan Belcher |
|
Solid performer to date |
|
7. |
Demorrio Williams |
|
Started strong in camp |
|
8. |
Cory Greenwood |
|
Slow starter, he’s gotten better |
|
9. |
Justin Cole |
|
Athlete will survive in kick game |
|
10. |
Gabe Miller |
|
Injury has him headed for IR |
|
11. |
Micah Johnson |
|
Hasn’t shown much to date |
|
12. |
Eric Bakhtiari |
|
Concussion stopped good camp |
|
13. |
Amara Kamara |
|
Smallish ILB, he shows up at ball |
|
14. |
Pierre Walters |
|
Doesn’t show much progress |
Comments: There will be 10 or 11 LBs based on special teams play and quite a battle for those last few spots.
Secondary
| Rank | Player | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Comment |
|
1. |
Brandon Carr |
|
He’s had a strong camp |
|
2. |
Brandon Flowers |
|
He too has had strong camp |
|
3. |
Eric Berry |
|
Makes three strong campers |
|
4. |
Kendrick Lewis |
|
Add another guy to the list |
|
5. |
Javier Arenas |
|
Solid pre-season to date |
|
6. |
Jalil Brown |
|
Rookie has shown nice skills |
|
7. |
Travis Daniels |
|
Veteran has played well |
|
8. |
Jon McGraw |
|
Veteran has played well too |
|
9. |
Reshard Langford |
|
Started strong, tailed off |
|
10. |
Demond Washington |
|
Rookie free agent has talent |
|
11. |
Sabby Piscitelli |
|
He lacks speed, but can hit |
|
12. |
Donald Washington |
|
Inconsistent on defense |
|
13. |
Quinten Lawrence |
|
Giant strides thanks to switch |
|
14. |
Ricky Price |
|
Hasn’t stood out much |
|
14. |
Javes Lewis |
|
Hasn’t stood out much 2 |
|
15. |
Mario Russell |
|
Hasn’t stood out much 3 |
Comments: The number figures to be four corners, four safeties and one player who can play both, more than likely a corner. There’s competition for last three spots.





































































































This is an excellent summary. It will be interesting to see who we add to the roster as other teams make their final cuts. Pulling for Tucker at WR. Gaither will be interesting to watch. What are they going to do with him? If he doesn’t play in the last pre-season game, will he put him on PUP? Hard to believe they cut him.
Gaither cant be placed on PUP he has all ready taking part in camp.
Great read. I agree with all. I hope Tucker makes team to Tenand6 I think we’re making a mistake keeping Urban. He hasn’t shown up in games. Tucker at least has not only been making strides in practice but has been making plays in games this preseason and last yr regular season. Urban I read about how well he does in practice but he just doesn’t seem to get open or do anything in games.
Pretty much agree.
I would expect both Baldwin and Gaither to start the season on Reserve/PUP allowing six more weeks to evaluate other guys in “real life” (eg. Tucker/Copper) – obviously both of them won’t contribute during the initial phase of the season anyway.
Butch lewis seems to leave a pretty good impression on most guys – would be a nice find to have an UDFA OL making the final 53.
TE is developping into an area of concern – the signing of Becht definitely highlights the fact that the brass is less than impressed.
The only guy I disagree being a lock is Jackie Battle. There will be a tough fight between him and Mike Cox for the final spot.
did they sign another linebacker since Miller is now on IR? All i heard about was the new tight end. Maybe they bring back that Andersen guy.
On the D line, Powe will make it. No way you go into the season with one true NT that’s in his mid 30s. Gotta have a rotation there. I would think the last D line spot is between Gales & Bair. I also think they’ll keep a NT on the practice squad. If Gregg goes down, they’ll need another one in a hurry. The TE position is a bit troubling. Somebody getting cut from another team could show up here. OL will be interesting too. Gaither will probably go PUP.
Nice Work Bob! Never commented before. A little prewiew of the premium site? I’m convinced if the mooney is there.
Lots of work there. Will be interesting, barring injury how the final roster turns out. I do not see a lot of surprises popping up, sign the team has gotten decidedly better. Wish we had an insider about Gaither, “I am 100%” and never seen again.
Bob,
This is great. It’s why I’ll subscribe.
Very good analysis by Bob. I too, am hoping Gaither can move up, but he just may be too injured to make the final cut. I’m gald to see that Bob says Tyson Jackson is showing improvement. That’s very positive. I don’t think they have signed another LB since Siler went on IR. They are probably waiting for the final cuts of other teams.
My personal depth chart as of now:
Offense
RT – B. Richardson, O’Callahan
RG – Asamoah, B. Lewis
OC – Wiegmann, Hudson
LG – Lilja, B. Lewis
LT – Albert, O’Callahan
QB – Cassel, Stanzi, Palko
RB – Jones, Charles, McCluster
FB – McClain
WR – Bowe, Tucker
Slot – Breaston, Colbert
WR – Urban, Copper
TE – Moeaki, Pope, O’Connell
Roundout Player: Cox
Becht may have a chance to crack the TE line-up. I predict both Baldwin and Gaither will start the season on Reserve/PUP.
Defense
DE – Dorsey, Bailey
NT – Gregg, Powe
DE – Jackson, Gilberry
WOLB – Hali, Sheffield
WILB – D. Johnson, D. Williams
SILB – Belcher, C. Greenwood
SOLB – Studebaker, Houston
CB – Carr, Daniels
NB – Arenas
CB – Flowers, Brown
FS – K. Lewis, McGraw
SS – Berry, Do. Washington, Langford
Roundout Players: Cole
Gales may have a shot at the DL, Walters/Sheffield will be interesting at OLB. Lawrence may replace Langford as the #10 DB if he gets more consistant.
The rest of the UDFA should try to find a spot on the PS – De. Washington, Walters, Bair, Mims, Harris are guys I would expect to go there.
KC_Guy,
A little cred check, here. You sound like you know what you are talking about but then if you did shouldn’t you know, already, any players who are now on the active roster are no longer eligible for the PUP list. A player must be put on Active PUP list BEFORE the very first minute of the very first training camp practice and that player must still be on the Active PUP list before he can be put on the Reserve PUP list. So there will be no new players on any PUP list from here on out.